Washington Water Power, Distribution Charge & Market Transform Programs (all sectors), Profile#126


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY




Washington Water Power’s Distribution Charge, formally known by its regulators as "the DSM Tariff Rider," is the most sophisticated model of its kind and a powerful harbinger of what may well become the future predominant energy efficiency services funding mechanism in a competitive utility environment. As similar structures have been proposed by states across the nation, Washington Water Power (WWP) has not only implemented the first "non-bypassable systems benefits charge" but is also the first utility to provide results on the success of the model’s implementation.


Concurrent to the introduction of the Distribution Charge was a complete overhaul of WWP’s approach to energy services. WWP has refined its focus on maintaining efficiency through market transformations, developing a constructive response to regional and national pressures. Its staff and advisors created new efficiency program designs to maximize effects while minimizing costs through an emphasis on becoming technical consultants and customer-focused energy service providers.


An enabling aspect of the Distribution Charge’s evolution has been the corporate culture within WWP. Despite projected excess capacity well past the year 2000, WWP’s management is committed to efficiency as a customer service and in this regard has responded to competition proactively. It developed the prototype Distribution Charge long before many others were aware of the concept. It was the first utility in the Northwest to propose that its largest customers gain direct access to their choice of suppliers. The Distribution Charge provides a pay-as-you go mechanism for continuing efficiency in a direct access environment and in the future will make WWP’s power prices easily comparable with competitors’ rates.



The DSM Issues Group, known as "DIG," was formed at the request of WWP's regulatory commission and was comprised of WWP staff along with representatives from seven key regional agencies. The utility’s openness in DIG’s extensive meetings over a 30-month period have been credited with shaping WWP's progressive energy services posture. Now its initiative to open up its territory to retail wheeling fills out the model as the cost of all kilowatt-hours sold within its service territory will include the Distribution Charge.



The Distribution Charge has increased electric rates by approximately 1.55% and gas rates by 0.52%. Thus typical monthly residential electricity bills have increased by 81¢ and gas bills by 16¢,... well within the bounds confirmed acceptable by a telling customer survey conducted by an independent market research firm. Thus WWP's pioneering efficiency model provides a win-win result for utility and customers alike.

 






 [CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE ENTIRE 27 PAGE PROFILE IN PDF FILE FORMAT]


This profile was produced by



Pacific Gas & Electric, Direct Assistance (low income retrofits), Profile #75

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY



Over its ten-year history Pacific Gas and Electric’s Direct Assistance programs (Energy Partners and Target Customer Appliance Program) have weatherized more than 600,000 low income homes at a total program cost of nearly a quarter of a billion dollars. In addition, since 1987 more than 90,000 appliances, primarily refrigerators that exceed federal appliance efficiency standards but also furnaces, evaporative coolers, water heaters, etc. have been replaced with energy-efficient models at no charge to low income customers. In addition over 70,000 compact fluorescent lamps were installed as part of TCAP.


Despite the fact that the Direct Assistance programs are clearly not cost effective as defined by the total resource cost test nor the rate impact measure test, the programs have been mandated by the California Public Utilities Commission which has considered the programs very important. So important, in fact, that PG&E’s shareholders were rewarded with over a million dollars in incentives for their $35 million programs in 1992.


The Energy Partners component of the Direct Assistance programs has been through an evolution that has enhanced the program, refining its delivery mechanism and quality control procedures, but which unfortunately complicates this profile somewhat and obfuscates its data. Originally part of PG&E’s Zero Interest Program, it is now its own program area. The program’s initial mandate was to provide "Big Six measures" to low income customers including attic insulation, weatherstripping, caulking, water heater blankets, low-flow showerheads, and duct insulation. Then PG&E added "Non "Big Six" measures to the program including fluorescent bulbs, outlet gaskets, faucet aerators, home repairs, pipe wraps, furnace filters, and evaporative cooler covers. In addition, an energy specialist spends up to three-quarters of an hour in each home providing owners with advice on energy saving tips, developing a personal energy savings plan, and completing an Energy Partners Agreement with the customer.


Currently PG&E’s program staff are experimenting with two pilot programs that may become incorporated into the program design in the future. The Blower Door Pilot was developed to test the appropriateness of using blower door equipment to determine optimal weatherization measures. In 1992, 1,392 blower door tests were completed. A Pen-Based Computer Pilot was tested in 88 of these homes to evaluate the effectiveness of creating a paperless program, a refinement that many utilities across the country may implement in the not-too-distant future!

 
[CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE ENTIRE 24 PAGE PROFILE IN PDF FILE FORMAT]


This profile was produced by